Skip to main content

    Sentimental Gifts

    145 gifts

    For those who value emotional connection

    Top Picks for Sentimental

    FAO Schwarz 12-inch Classic Cutie Fox Plush

    FAO Schwarz 12-inch Classic Cutie Fox Plush

    By FAO Schwarz

    Check price on Amazon
    FUJIFILM Instax Mini Pastel Galaxy Instant Film

    FUJIFILM Instax Mini Pastel Galaxy Instant Film

    By FUJIFILM

    Check price on Amazon
    Mini Brands Create Mini Masterpieces Series 1 Capsule 2-Pack

    Mini Brands Create Mini Masterpieces Series 1 Capsule 2-Pack

    By ZURU

    Check price on Amazon
    Squishmallows Original 8in Harpo the Maroon Elephant Butterfly – Official Jazwares Plush (Little)

    Squishmallows Original 8in Harpo the Maroon Elephant Butterfly – Official Jazwares Plush (Little)

    By Jazwares

    Check price on Amazon
    WinCraft Toronto Tempo Collector's Pin

    WinCraft Toronto Tempo Collector's Pin

    By WinCraft

    $9.09Price as of Nov 22
    Toronto Raptors Framed Black Team Logo Jersey Display Case

    Toronto Raptors Framed Black Team Logo Jersey Display Case

    By Fanatics Authentic

    $280.69Price as of Nov 22
    Unisex Nike Bordeaux Toronto Tempo Victory Custom Jersey - Explorer Edition

    Unisex Nike Bordeaux Toronto Tempo Victory Custom Jersey - Explorer Edition

    By Nike

    $119.99Price as of Nov 22
    Tracy McGrady Toronto Raptors Autographed Purple Mitchell & Ness Swingman Jersey

    Tracy McGrady Toronto Raptors Autographed Purple Mitchell & Ness Swingman Jersey

    By Fanatics Authentic

    $451.49Price as of Nov 22
    WinCraft Toronto Raptors Court Collector Pin

    WinCraft Toronto Raptors Court Collector Pin

    By WinCraft

    $13.29Price as of Nov 22
    22-inch Labrador Plush Adopt-A-Pets

    22-inch Labrador Plush Adopt-A-Pets

    By FAO Schwarz

    Check price on Amazon
    AncestryDNA + Traits Genetic Test Kit

    AncestryDNA + Traits Genetic Test Kit

    By AncestryDNA

    Check price on Amazon
    Aura Carver WiFi Digital Picture Frame (Black)

    Aura Carver WiFi Digital Picture Frame (Black)

    By Aura

    Check price on Amazon
    AW BRIDAL Silk Robes for Women Short Bridesmaid Robes for Bridal Party

    AW BRIDAL Silk Robes for Women Short Bridesmaid Robes for Bridal Party

    By AW BRIDAL

    Check price on Amazon
    Baby GUND My First Teddy Bear — Tan, 10"

    Baby GUND My First Teddy Bear — Tan, 10"

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon
    Basket Ball: The Story of the All-American Game

    Basket Ball: The Story of the All-American Game

    Check price on Amazon
    Bedtime Originals Interactive Airplane/Airport Plush Play Set with Stuffed Toys

    Bedtime Originals Interactive Airplane/Airport Plush Play Set with Stuffed Toys

    By Bedtime Originals

    Check price on Amazon
    BEST PAPER GREETINGS 50 Pack Floral Wedding Advice Cards for Bride, Bridal Shower Games (5x7 in)

    BEST PAPER GREETINGS 50 Pack Floral Wedding Advice Cards for Bride, Bridal Shower Games (5x7 in)

    By BEST PAPER GREETINGS

    Check price on Amazon
    Binibi Feliz Navidad - Christmas Songs in Spanish - Musical Book for Babies & Toddlers

    Binibi Feliz Navidad - Christmas Songs in Spanish - Musical Book for Babies & Toddlers

    By Binibi

    Check price on Amazon
    Brick Shop Masters of the Universe — Attack of the Collector Airship

    Brick Shop Masters of the Universe — Attack of the Collector Airship

    By Brick Shop

    Check price on Amazon
    Cali's Nutcracker Music Book for Toddlers (1–3 years)

    Cali's Nutcracker Music Book for Toddlers (1–3 years)

    By Cali's Books

    Check price on Amazon
    Chefman Electric Kettle with Temperature Control & Tea Infuser (1.8L)

    Chefman Electric Kettle with Temperature Control & Tea Infuser (1.8L)

    By Chefman

    Check price on Amazon
    Classic Collector's Handbook: An Official Guide to the First 151 Pokemon

    Classic Collector's Handbook: An Official Guide to the First 151 Pokemon

    Check price on Amazon
    Customized Retirement Plaque 8x10, Personalized Gift for Coworker, Award for Women and Men

    Customized Retirement Plaque 8x10, Personalized Gift for Coworker, Award for Women and Men

    Check price on Amazon
    Custom Multi-Image Collage Canvas Print with Personalized Photos - 8"x12" (Collage Photo-14)

    Custom Multi-Image Collage Canvas Print with Personalized Photos - 8"x12" (Collage Photo-14)

    Check price on Amazon
    Custom Star Map Print Framed Night Sky Poster (Date & Location)

    Custom Star Map Print Framed Night Sky Poster (Date & Location)

    Check price on Amazon
    Custom Team Plaque with Photo, Logo & Message (5 x 7")

    Custom Team Plaque with Photo, Logo & Message (5 x 7")

    Check price on Amazon
    Emotional Support Chicken Nugget Plush Set

    Emotional Support Chicken Nugget Plush Set

    By Relatable

    Check price on Amazon
    Emotional Support Pals Cheez-It, Cute Stuffed Animals by Relatable

    Emotional Support Pals Cheez-It, Cute Stuffed Animals by Relatable

    By Relatable

    Check price on Amazon
    Endless Games Fourth Wing: Rise of the Wingleader Board Game

    Endless Games Fourth Wing: Rise of the Wingleader Board Game

    By Endless Games

    Check price on Amazon
    EXPRESSIONS Toronto Raptors Fleece Throw Blanket, 50 x 60 in

    EXPRESSIONS Toronto Raptors Fleece Throw Blanket, 50 x 60 in

    By EXPRESSIONS

    Check price on Amazon
    FAO Schwarz 16-inch Toy Soldier Plush Bear

    FAO Schwarz 16-inch Toy Soldier Plush Bear

    By FAO Schwarz

    Check price on Amazon
    FAO Schwarz 22" Adopt-A-Pets Mix Pups Plush Cockapoo

    FAO Schwarz 22" Adopt-A-Pets Mix Pups Plush Cockapoo

    By FAO Schwarz

    Check price on Amazon
    FAO Schwarz Charm Squad Cute Treats Bracelet & 4 Charms Set

    FAO Schwarz Charm Squad Cute Treats Bracelet & 4 Charms Set

    By FAO Schwarz

    Check price on Amazon
    F.A.O. Schwarz Cuddle Baby Doll 35cm Brown Hair

    F.A.O. Schwarz Cuddle Baby Doll 35cm Brown Hair

    By F.A.O. Schwarz

    Check price on Amazon
    Fisher-Price 4-in-1 Cuddle & Crawl Duck

    Fisher-Price 4-in-1 Cuddle & Crawl Duck

    By Fisher-Price

    Check price on Amazon
    Fisher-Price Laugh and Learn Song and Story Chair

    Fisher-Price Laugh and Learn Song and Story Chair

    By Fisher-Price

    Check price on Amazon
    FUJIFILM Instax Mini 13 Instant Camera - Candy Pink

    FUJIFILM Instax Mini 13 Instant Camera - Candy Pink

    By FUJIFILM

    Check price on Amazon
    Fujifilm INSTAX Mini Evo Hybrid Instant Camera - Black

    Fujifilm INSTAX Mini Evo Hybrid Instant Camera - Black

    By Fujifilm

    Check price on Amazon
    Fujifilm Instax Mini Link 3 Smartphone Printer (Clay White)

    Fujifilm Instax Mini Link 3 Smartphone Printer (Clay White)

    By Fujifilm

    Check price on Amazon
    Funko Pop! Bitty Box Bundle - Harry Potter

    Funko Pop! Bitty Box Bundle - Harry Potter

    By Funko

    Check price on Amazon
    Funko Pop! NBA: Toronto Raptors - The Raptor Vinyl Figure

    Funko Pop! NBA: Toronto Raptors - The Raptor Vinyl Figure

    By Funko

    Check price on Amazon
    Glocusent Rechargeable Book Light with Bendable Neck (Grey)

    Glocusent Rechargeable Book Light with Bendable Neck (Grey)

    By Glocusent

    Check price on Amazon
    GUND Baby Peeki Puppy Animated Plush — 12” Singing Peek‑a‑Boo Toy

    GUND Baby Peeki Puppy Animated Plush — 12” Singing Peek‑a‑Boo Toy

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon
    GUND Cozys Cow Plush 10 in

    GUND Cozys Cow Plush 10 in

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon
    GUND Forever Friends Muttsy 14-Inch Puppy Plush

    GUND Forever Friends Muttsy 14-Inch Puppy Plush

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon
    GUND Forever Friends Philbin 12-Inch Teddy Bear

    GUND Forever Friends Philbin 12-Inch Teddy Bear

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon
    GUND Forever Friends Toothpick 15-Inch Teddy Bear Plush Toy

    GUND Forever Friends Toothpick 15-Inch Teddy Bear Plush Toy

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon
    GUND Kai 12-Inch Teddy Bear

    GUND Kai 12-Inch Teddy Bear

    By GUND

    Check price on Amazon

    Showing 48 of 145

    FAQs About Sentimental

    What are good sentimental gifts?

    Great sentimental gifts balance personal relevance with everyday usefulness. We've curated 145 options on this page, ranging from budget-friendly picks to premium standouts. For a shortlist tailored to your specific recipient, use our free AI gift finder.

    How do I choose the best sentimental gift?

    Think about the recipient's interests and how they spend their time, set a budget you're comfortable with, and favor quality and thoughtfulness over a high price. Reading recent reviews helps you avoid duds and pick something they'll actually use.

    How much should I spend on sentimental gifts?

    There's no fixed rule. It depends on your relationship to the recipient and the occasion. You'll find thoughtful sentimental gifts at every price point here, so you can give something meaningful without overspending. A well-chosen modest gift often beats an expensive generic one.

    Where can I find unique sentimental gifts?

    This page collects curated sentimental gifts from trusted retailers. For something more personalized, our free AI gift finder generates unique ideas based on the recipient's personality, interests, and your budget in seconds.